I'm thinking about a brand new Golf Alltrack. I found a couple at my local dealer that are the S model with the 6 speed manual. I'd appreciate hearing ownership experiences from any Alltrack owners out there.
I bought a 2019 SEL automatic last summer. I've put 6000 mi. on it so far, get 28 - 31mpg with climate control in use 99% of the time. I love the car, no complaints. We've had no snow on Cape Cod this winter so I can't comment on winter driving. Handling, comfort (ride / cabin noise) all great. I'm not a spirited driver but have had to make sudden stops a couple of times and make sudden swerves at speed. Outstanding braking and stability. I did change the tires. While the Continental's that came on the car weren't exactly loud, they felt "hard". I bought Vredestein Pro Contact. They're great, softer, quieter, better control. Good luck. Hope this helps.